Sign up to view this video
Join NowPositive Reinforcement vs Positive Punishment: Training in the Shelter
Summary
Positive Reinforcement in Animal Shelters
Laurie and Donna discuss their respective locations and experiences before delving into the main topic of positive reinforcement in animal shelters. Donna, who has 25 years of experience in animal sheltering, shares that her shelter has implemented various enrichment programs, including play groups and office rotations for dogs. Laurie expresses her goal of helping shelters embrace behavior-forward approaches, noting the differences between shelters in America and the UK. The conversation then shifts to focus on the use of positive reinforcement in shelters, with Laurie mentioning that some shelters embrace it without fully understanding its nuances.
Operant Conditioning in Shelter Training
Laurie explains the four quadrants of operant conditioning in dog training: positive reinforcement, negative punishment, positive punishment, and negative reinforcement. She emphasizes the importance of using positive reinforcement techniques in shelter environments to minimize stress and frustration for the animals. Laurie provides examples of each quadrant and discusses the potential drawbacks of using punishment-based methods, particularly in shelters where dogs are already under stress. She recommends that shelter staff focus on positive reinforcement strategies whenever possible to teach desired behaviors and reduce the risk of negative side effects.
Stress Management Strategies for Dogs
Laurie discusses strategies for managing stressed dogs in shelter environments. She emphasizes the importance of helping dogs de-stress after leaving their kennels, using positive reinforcement techniques like food scatters or brief runs. Laurie recommends practicing door exercises in less stressful environments to help dogs generalize the behavior. She also explains the concepts of classical conditioning and classical counter conditioning, highlighting their relevance in changing dogs' emotional responses to various stimuli in shelter settings.
Dog Behavior Modification Techniques
Laurie discusses techniques for modifying dog behavior through classical conditioning and counter-conditioning. She explains how to gradually introduce new stimuli to dogs with fear or aggression issues, starting with neutral objects and progressing to the problematic ones. Laurie also describes how to apply these methods in shelter environments to reduce dogs' excitement when approached for walks. She emphasizes the importance of analyzing individual dogs' thresholds and triggers to tailor behavior modification strategies effectively.
Shelter Dog Behavior Management Strategies
Laurie discusses strategies for managing dogs with low frustration thresholds, particularly in shelter environments. She emphasizes the importance of clear signals, providing multiple outlets for engagement, and using enrichment items to help dogs transition between activities. Laurie suggests preparing "busy boxes" or other calming activities for dogs returning to kennels after high-energy sessions to reduce frustration and negative associations. She also highlights the need for individualized approaches to meet each dog's specific needs, recommending early identification and intervention to prevent behavior challenges in shelter dogs.
Animal Shelter Enrichment Strategies
Laurie discusses the importance of enrichment programs in animal shelters, highlighting the effectiveness of rewarding quiet behavior in kennels. She recommends Mick's webinar for those interested in robust enrichment programs. Laurie then explains the difference between desensitization and flooding, emphasizing the need for controlled, gradual exposure when helping dogs overcome fears. She cautions against forcing fearful dogs into overwhelming situations, as it can increase their anxiety and hinder learning.
Fearful Dog Training Strategies
Laurie shares her experience working with fearful dogs, particularly those from puppy mills. She describes a challenging incident where a dog reacted negatively to leash pressure, setting back their training progress. Laurie emphasizes the importance of desensitization over flooding when working with fearful animals, including dogs and feral kittens. She provides an example of successful desensitization with a fearful dog at a shelter, gradually building trust through food and patience. Laurie suggests strategies like cohousing with confident dogs and using foster homes to help fearful dogs feel safe and adapt.
Dog Reactivity Reduction Strategies
Donna and Laurie discuss strategies to reduce dog reactivity in the shelter environment. Laurie suggests using mirrors in hallways, implementing a walkie-talkie system, and soundproofing the keypad area to minimize noise-induced reactions. They also explore ways to make kennel environments more comfortable for dogs, such as adding furniture and preparing food in advance. Laurie recommends having staff spend time with dogs in the office before taking them back to their kennels and creating positive associations with returning to the kennel space.